America's Choice Insurance Agency logo
Licensed Medicare Guidance, Nationwide

Medicare, explained by someone in your corner.

Compare Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D plans with a licensed local agent — no cost, no pressure, no obligation to enroll.

America's Choice Insurance Agency logo

Licensed · Independent · Multi-Carrier

We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.
40+States Licensed
Multi-CarrierPlans Compared Side by Side
$0Cost To Meet With An Agent
CMSCompliant Marketing & Enrollment
About Us

Local markets, known inside and out

Medicare isn't one-size-fits-all — the carriers, hospital networks, and pharmacies available to you can change from one county to the next. America's Choice is built around knowing those local markets, not just the national plan brochures.

Our agents live and work in the communities they serve. That means real familiarity with the doctors, hospital systems, and pharmacy networks your neighbors actually use — so the plan we recommend fits your area, not just your zip code on a chart.

More About Us

Why Local Knowledge Matters

Two people with the same Medicare Advantage plan can have very different experiences depending on which hospital system and pharmacy network serve their area.

  • We track carrier networks market by market, not just state by state
  • We know which plans actually perform well in your local area
  • Agents are reachable locally, not routed through a call center
Coverage Options

Three ways we help you choose

Every situation is different — your prescriptions, your doctors, your travel, your budget. We walk through your options in plain language, then let you decide.

Medicare Advantage

Part C

Bundled medical and often drug coverage through private carriers, frequently with extra benefits like dental, vision, or hearing.

  • Often $0 monthly premium plans available
  • Network-based; may include extra benefits
  • Annual and special enrollment periods apply

Medicare Supplement

Medigap

Works alongside Original Medicare to help cover copays, coinsurance, and deductibles — helpful if you travel or want provider flexibility.

  • Use any doctor who accepts Medicare
  • Standardized plan letters (A, G, N, and more)
  • Predictable out-of-pocket costs

Prescription Drug Plans

Part D

Standalone drug coverage designed around your specific medications and pharmacy preferences.

  • We check your prescriptions against formularies
  • Compare pharmacy networks near you
  • Avoid late-enrollment penalties
How It Works

One conversation. Every option on the table.

1

Tell us what matters

Doctors, medications, and budget — a short conversation, by phone or in person.

2

We compare plans for you

We review eligible plans from the carriers we represent in your area, side by side.

3

You choose, we handle paperwork

No pressure to enroll. If you're ready, we help you complete enrollment correctly.

For Agents & Agencies

Build your Medicare book with real infrastructure behind you

Whether you're an independent agent or you run a smaller agency, America's Choice gives you contracting, back-office support, and marketing — so you spend your time in front of clients, not paperwork.

Independent Agents

Write Business Faster

Get appointed with top-rated carriers under our FMO and start writing business quickly.

  • Fast carrier contracting & certification support
  • Competitive, vested commission structure
  • Lead programs and co-op marketing options
  • CMS-compliant marketing materials, pre-approved
  • A real person to call when a case gets complicated
Apply as an Agent
Smaller Agencies

Scale Without Losing Your Identity

Keep your agency's identity and client relationships while plugging into carrier access and support built for scale.

  • Multi-carrier contracting for your whole downline
  • Agency-level reporting and commission tracking
  • Compliance support for AEP, OEP, and SEP marketing
  • Training for new and part-time agents
  • Growth planning as your book matures
Talk About Partnering

Carrier Access

Broad portfolio of Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D carriers.

Compliance Support

Marketing review and guidance aligned to current CMS Medicare Communications rules.

Technology

Quoting tools, CRM access, and enrollment platforms to keep your pipeline organized.

Real Support

Direct access to agency leadership — not a ticket queue.

Who We Are

Meet the leadership behind America's Choice

Licensed, experienced, and accountable — the team setting the standard for how we serve beneficiaries and support our agents.

Nicholas Bergami

Partner, President & COO

Bio coming soon.

Photo coming soon

Matt Santangelo

Matt Santangelo

Partner, Chief Sales Officer

Chief Sales Officer following the merger of his agency, East Coast Senior Plans, where he led 30 independent field agents for 15 years.

Arthur Cruz

Director of Carrier Relations

Ten years helping people find Medicare coverage they can count on, with deep roots in the local doctors, pharmacies, and community organizations he serves.

Photo coming soon

Book a Free Consultation

Pick a time that works for you

Schedule a no-cost Medicare plan review directly on our calendar — no phone tag, no waiting for a callback.

Prefer to talk first? Call (888) 676-5937 or use the contact form below.

Get Started

Ready to talk it through?

Reach a licensed agent for a no-cost Medicare plan review, or start a conversation about contracting with America's Choice.

1280 SW 36th Avenue, Suite 208
Pompano Beach, FL 33069

Request a Free Plan Review

A licensed agent will follow up — no cost, no obligation to enroll.

Submitting this form does not enroll you in a Medicare plan. Fields marked without "(optional)" are required to submit.